Pension Company

Inheritance Tax on UK Pensions – Beware HMRC may look for inheritance tax on your fund!

UK Personal Pensions can fall into two camps with regard to death benefits which are largely determined pre and post retirement.

  1. Un-crystallised funds (where tax free cash and/or income has not been taken).

100% of the fund within the lifetime allowance can be paid as a lump sum to beneficiaries and with an appropriate Trust can be paid prior to probate and outside the estate for Inheritance tax purposes (read on!).

  1. Crystallised benefits (where cash and/or income has or is being drawn).

If the crystallised fund is an unsecured pension (income drawdown) then on death the members fund can be paid to beneficiaries minus a 35% tax charge. Or if post age 75 years on death, a 70% tax charge is made and the residual fund passes into the estate and can be chargeable to inheritance tax. Commonly a tax charge of 82% is quoted in these circumstances.

A worrying complex court case for many has a previously unforeseen consequence!

Fryer & Others vs. HMRC  released on 17th February 2010 has created a dilemma for those deferring taking pension benefits post the pension normal retirement age.

People who decide not to take Pension benefits at normal retirement age thought they had the comfort of knowing until age 75 years the UK pension fund can be left and 100% will be paid to beneficiaries on death - an attractive planning tool.

HMRC’s view appears to be different.

All Pensions will have a normal retirement age of anything from 55 years to 75 years old. The majority will be age 60 yrs or 65 yrs at which point a retirement benefits illustration is issued by the Pension Company or Trustee.

HMRC have argued successfully that if you defer taking retirement benefits beyond the stated retirement age then a transfer of value has taken place.

The successful HMRC argument is that by failing to take pension benefits (tax free cash and an annuity or unsecured pension) the value of assets in the discretionary trust appointing death benefits has been increased.

The judge concluded that the pension holder had a valuable right and by not exercising that right at normal retirement age it allowed the whole value to be exempt from the estate. The estate was therefore diminished and the condition for the application of Section 3 (3) IHTA 1984 had been fulfilled.

The taxable value was discounted by the judge after taking actuarial evidence but this still left over 60% of the fund subject to inheritance tax.

Interestingly there was no deliberate tax planning strategy merely the Pension holder did not need the benefits.  

QROPS (Qualifying recognised Overseas Pension Schemes) and QNUPS (Qualifying Non UK Pension Schemes) have seen recent legislation specifically clarifying exemption from UK Inheritance Tax. This may appear at odds with this court case but for a non UK resident or someone considering living abroad with UK Pension funds it highlights the importance of considering these qualifying overseas pensions to reduce future tax burdens.

For more information contact:

 

www.gerardassociates.co.uk

Tel: +44 (0) 1884 250118

 

Understanding Residence, Ordinary Residence and Domicile

The terms of Residence, Ordinary Residence and Domicile are complex but crucial for individuals considering Qualifying Recognised Overseas Pension Schemes (QROPS).

This note aims to give a brief overview of the various terms and their importance from a taxation perspective.

We’ll start with some important definitions:

  • Residence - the category in any one tax year
  • Ordinary Residence - category on a regular basis
  • Domicile - the country of permanent home.

 

UK Residence

 Your UK resident status is determined each tax year from 6th April to 5th April. You are definitely resident if you spend 183 days or more in the UK. Days of arrival and departure are normally disregarded. HMRC are aware this may distort the time you actually spend in the UK. Therefore in extreme circumstances will allow nights spent in the UK. So a person arriving one day and leaving the next would count as one day in the UK. Check before committing to this arrangement with your tax professional.

The 183 days do not have to be consecutive.

Ordinary Residence

 The test for ordinary residence is whether visits to the UK are in a regular pattern over several years.

The ruling is confirmed after one year provided that visits to the UK have been more than 90 days. Or vice versa you are not Ordinarily Resident if you spend less than 91 days in the UK.

Otherwise you remain ordinarily resident for three years unless you do not visit the UK at all in one tax year. After three years the situation is reviewed and enforced retrospectively if required by HMRC.

Habitual and Substantial Test

Residency can also be determined if you make habitual and substantial visits to the UK.

  • Habitual - continuing over four consecutive tax year.
  • Substantial - if visits average 91 days a tax year or more. The average being taken over a maximum of four tax years

Domicile

 

Residence can be determined by a set of rules but Domicile is a legal term.

 

Domicile can be explained as the country the individual would consider home and where they would expect to return after a period abroad. It is therefore a more permanent concept than residence.

In some countries Domicile can mean the right of residence which is not the meaning in the UK.

An individual can acquire a Domicile of Choice so long as a move abroad has the intention of permanency. There are no set rules but physically residing permanently there is one of the most common.

HMRC will balance the ties with Domicile of origin with Domicile of choice and make a judgement.

You are generally Domicile in the UK if you have been resident for tax purposes for at least 17 out of the previous 20 years. Tax residence is determined by the above rules.

Deemed Domicile for Inheritance Tax

Whilst the purpose of this note is with regard to QROPS the effect of Domicile has great implications for Inheritance tax.

QROPS are an exempt transfer so not liable to UK Inheritance Tax.

Not Resident and Not Ordinarily Resident

If you are UK Domicile and go abroad for sufficient time:

  • Earned Income - There is no income tax on employment income outside of the UK. Earnings in the UK remain taxable unless incidental to employment abroad.
  • Investment Income - There is no UK liability to overseas income and no tax is deducted at source from UK bank and Building Society deposit accounts provided you supply a non residency certificate.
  • UK investment income - is taxable but a non resident's UK tax liability cannot be more than the tax due on the non resident's income if investment income were excluded and no personal allowance given.
  • Pension Income - The UK state Pension and other Pension income are taxable (important; see notes on Double Taxation Agreement).
  • Income from UK property is taxable.

Double Taxation Relief

 

Where a liability to tax on income and or gains is from one country and the individual is resident for tax purposes in another there may be a liability under each country's tax legislation. The UK has negotiated double tax treaties with many countries around the world to help avoid this problem.

 

(For Non UK Residents) Exemptions may exist where non residents receive relief from UK tax on the following types of income:

  • Pensions (other than government pensions)
  • Royalties
  • Dividends
  • Interest

Individuals must be liable to tax in the country concerned before qualifying for relief from the UK tax.

Non Resident and Pensions

Individual advice must be taken regarding taxation of Pensions abroad. Whilst in its simplest form of receiving a Pension Income (such as Income Drawdown) from the UK, the Pension Company will remit the income to you Gross with no tax deducted.

Do not treat this Gross payment as an exemption from tax. The paying agent or Pension company will report that information and information about the income payment to its own tax authority, who will pass it on to the tax authority of the country or territory in which the individual is resident.
Many European and other countries have different rules for taxing Pensions which can reduce your tax liability significantly. You do need to structure your income correctly in order to benefit from lower taxation.

As already seen there are significant further advantages via QROPS which will deliver a highly flexible and tax efficient retirement plan compared with a UK scheme.

Important Notice

Gerard Associates Ltd. Financial Advisory Services does not provide this information as advice and nothing contained in this briefing should be construed as such. We make every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information but cannot be held responsible for any liability arising.
It is essential that all clients seek tax advice specific to their own personal circumstances with the relevant tax professional of the jurisdiction(s) in which you are liable to tax.

This has been prepared based on our understanding of current legislation and tax practice as at the date above. The information is specific to QROPS and does not cover all the aspects of domicile and residency with regard to other tax implications and liabilities. This information is subject to change, and may result in income tax consequences different from those detailed below.

We cannot accept responsibility for its interpretation or any future changes to law.

Any advice and recommendations will be given in writing.

How much will an Overseas Pension transfer cost me?

Anyone with a pension in a UK registered scheme can make an overseas transfer to a Qualifying Recognised Overseas Pension Scheme (QROPS). But before undertaking such a transfer, it is important to establish the charges you will pay, both to conduct the transfer and as a member of the QROPS scheme.

One must also consider the stability and regulatory environment in which the QROPS exists. For example, the Isle of Man is home to many household names in pension provision and large Merchant Banks, with a variety of different QROPS offering. The regulatory and compliance regimes are all government controlled in a jurisdiction with no language barriers to UK nationals. Funds can be held in and paid out in Sterling, Euros or US Dollars. These jurisdictions have an existing structure which will not change in the foreseeable future.

The Government Regulatory controls and investor compensation schemes can even surpass the protections in place in the UK. The Guernsey Financial Services Commission is a good example of a regulatory body. Other jurisdictions may offer attractive benefits, but with accompanying problems and risks. Having an awareness of where your QROPS will be held is essential. Understanding the regulatory regime of a completely different country is a tricky proposition, since business practices and Government actions may be dramatically different from those to which you are accustomed.

The advice you get on QROPS should be totally transparent. QROPS charges, if done correctly, are exactly the same as those to a UK based Personal Pension or Self Invested Personal Pension (SIPP). If you’re considering an offshore transfer and you can’t get a clear, unambiguous statement of the charges you will face, then we’d advise you to give the scheme a wide berth. Example of Charges There are two main components to a QROPS. The Master Trust which is the entity authorised as a QROPS. The Trust administrators have given HMRC an assurance that the scheme is suitable to receive UK Personal Pension transfers and they will notify HMRC of transactions for five complete UK tax years after you become non UK resident. The underlying investments can be cash, and asset backed such as collectives, equities and property. You will normally have a Master Trust provider and then decide with your Financial Adviser where the underlying investments are placed. There is dual charging as you need to pay the Master Trust for the administration and the investment vehicle, such OEIC’s (unit trusts) for the investment management. Packaged arrangements will normally be the most competitive where the provider operates both the QROPS and underlying investments.

For most people if the establishment fees exceed 3% to 4% (that includes the Master trust and initial charges of any collective investments) then take a close look at other arrangements. Remember the administration of a QROPS in the long run is easier than a UK Personal Pension. Whilst QROPS are a new niche product, you don’t need to accept unrealistic charges. With living abroad it’s always worth making sure that you have access to free on-line valuations otherwise getting up to date information via the post could be difficult.

The main reasons people consider QROPS are: No restrictions on the level of income at retirement after five full UK tax years of non UK tax residency (from 6th April 2011 the UK also introduced flexible drawdown which for some alows far greater access to pension funds). No requirement to buy an annuity or at any age (from 6th April 2011 the UK also removed this requirement). On death pass the fund intact to spouse and heirs’ UK pension death tax (now 55% in a UK registered pension drawdown fund and post age 75 years) and inheritance tax free. No liability to changes in UK Pension taxation or legislation.

To any individual in foreign lands or considering living abroad, QROPS potentially offer more flexible terms than in the UK and we believe without any major negative points. You will of course be subject to tax in your country of tax residency on income and capital etc. And we ask you seek advice from a tax professional in that jurisdiction.

Full Access to your Funds

 

QROPS providers are recognised by HMRC under two main pieces of legislation: 

  1. Give an undertaking to HMRC that 70% of crystallised Pension funds are used to provide a lifetime income. This is more flexible than the UK arrangements which are linked to Government Actuaries Rates (GAD).
  2. A country or territory with which the UK has a double taxation agreement in force that contains provisions as to exchange of information and non-discrimination. Go to http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/rpsmmanual/RPSM14101046.htm  to see the list of countries. 
    • The scheme is open to persons resident and non-resident.
    • The scheme is established in a country with a system of personal taxation as required.
    • The scheme is approved, recognised and registered with the relevant tax authority as a pension scheme.

Many QROPS providers give an undertaking to HMRC that 70% of crystallised Pension funds are used to provide a lifetime income. This is more flexible than the UK arrangements which are linked to Government Actuaries Rates (GAD).

Be aware that many jurisdictions do not recognise tax free cash. Most UK Pensions can have 25% of the fund paid as tax free cash but if you are resident elsewhere there may be a liability on this sum. Check with us before crystallising your Pension.

QROPS - the right choice for me? It is essential that you don’t transfer your pension without being fully informed of all the features and benefits of your existing scheme. For a no-obligations quotation, contact Gerard Associates now. The next stage is to get a letter of authority from you so we can approach your Pension Company for the relevant information about your existing scheme(s). We will then compile a full report for you before any advice is implemented. There will be occasions that we advise not to transfer but ultimately the informed choice is yours.

Syndicate content